Guinness World Records reinstates Billy Mitchell’s Pac-Man and Donkey Kong scores
Competitive arcade gamer Billy Mitchell has scored a major victory in the fight to clear his name from accusations of cheating. Guinness World Records, the international record-keeping organization, has reversed its 2018 decision to purge his scores from the record books.
Twin Galaxies, Guinness’s one-time partner for video game records, wiped Mitchell’s entries from its scoreboards and banished him for life following an investigation that found a number of technical inconsistencies in tapes of Mitchell’s records and concluded that the games in question could not have been played on genuine arcade hardware, as was required by the rules at the time. Though Twin Galaxies’ official statements did not state the games were played on an emulator, some technical signatures in the footage are consistent with some versions of the emulator MAME, according to a number of experts in the field.
Mitchell, who famously featured in the 2007 documentary King of Kong: A Fistful of a Quarters, has been steadfast in his denials of wrongdoing.
In a video announcing the reinstatement, Guinness World Records editor-in-chief Craig Glenday said there “wasn’t sufficient evidence to support the disqualification across the board.”
“In cases such as this where there is debate, we would typically defer to the original contemporaneous adjudication, and this is the case here,” Glenday added.
A statement accompanying the video references “compelling new evidence,” but any new evidence does not appear to have been made public as of yet. It’s unclear whether Mitchell presented any additional information beyond the evidence package he submitted to Twin Galaxies in 2019. We may hear about the new evidence when (or if) Mitchell’s lawsuit against Twin Galaxies proceeds to trial. Certainly, a full and public accounting of Mitchell’s current defense would be a reasonable next step if he seeks to repair his public image.
Mitchell’s reinstated records are as follows:
- 3 July 1999 – First Perfect Score on Pac-Man – 3,333,360 Points
- 7 November 1982 – Highest score on Donkey Kong – 874,300 Points
- 4 June 2005 – Highest score on Donkey Kong – 1,047,200 Points
- 14 July 2007 – Highest score on Donkey Kong – 1,050,200 Points
- 31 July 2010 – Highest score on Donkey Kong – 1,062,800 Points
Mitchell is not the current world record holder in Donkey Kong—that honor belongs to Robbie Lakeman, who set a score of 1,260,700 live on Twitch just four days ago—so many of these records are historical. But Guinness does now recognize Mitchell as holding a number of “first” records that are still live on the books, so to speak:
- 7 November 1982 – First gamer to reach the kill screen on Donkey Kong
- 4 June 2005 – First gamer to score 1 million points on Donkey Kong
As for what’s next for Billy Mitchell?
“Do I want future world records? I guess it’s too difficult to say no to that, so maybe I do,” Mitchell said. “But more than anything, I want to get back to work. The ambassadorship, competitive gaming, the legacy that that’s going to leave behind long after we’re gone—that’s my true passion, and that’s what I’ll be doing.”
It’s been a surprisingly big month for Donkey Kong news. In addition to this decision and Lakeman’s new record, Mitchell’s King of Kong rival Steve Wiebe recently announced his return to competitive Donkey Kong play.